One of Marilyn Manson's bodyguards has won a court battle against a photographer who claimed he was beaten up at a concert. A Los Angeles judge has ruled that snapper Ruben Navarrete failed to present enough evidence that he was injured by the security guard at a Manson show in 2004. Navarette alleged the bodyguard "grabbed him and put him in a choke hold" and then demanded he "erase the portions of his videotape that contained the images of Marilyn Manson." The photographer initially named Manson as a defendant, but, according to, the judge threw that part of the case out.