"He was on my talk show for Vh1 and I went a year without dating anybody. So I don't know if I was really randy or really ready but he was there and I gave him my phone number, which I've never given a guy (before)... but I was interested. It took two weeks for him to call me back and I thought for sure he was playing for a different team, if you know what I'm saying." Model/actress Jenny McCarthy felt sure her new boyfriend Donnie Wahlberg was gay after handing him her digits.