We Were Soldiers

"Good"

We Were Soldiers Review


Mel Gibson plays yet another idealized and idealistic father-of-five war hero, bursting at the seams with charge-leading integrity in "We Were Soldiers," a detailed and staggering account of the first harrowing battle of the Vietnam War.

This may sound like a bit much to take so soon after he single-handedly vanquished the British as a choleric colonial in "The Patriot." But Gibson is well cast in this far heavier and historically accurate picture that only falls back on hackneyed Hollywoodisms when it takes a break from the battlefield (and that isn't very often).

Gibson stars as Lt. Col. Hal Moore, the man who reluctantly but boldly lead the first American ground troops into the Ia Drang Valley on November 14, 1965 -- 11 years after the occupying French were trounced in the same location (as established in the film's brutal World War I-styled prologue).

It becomes clear even before Moore and his Seventh Cavalry (the same unit General Custer commanded) leave Fort Benning, Georgia -- kissing their wives and kids goodbye in a very affecting pre-dawn moment frozen in time -- that he knows they're headed into a near-impossible situation.

Within minutes of disembarking from a squadron of low-flying helicopters (an incredible overhead shot shows the troops rushing into position through a field of tall grass flattened by rotary wind), the Seventh is attacked by Viet Cong defenders, bisected and pinned down for a two-day firefight that makes the recent "Black Hawk Down" look like a minor skirmish.

Under-prepared, outnumbered and ill-informed about the resistance they'd encounter, the unit loses men left and right in a cinematic but chillingly realistic and tensely sustained battle that takes lives without warning and without melodramatic fanfare no matter how central a character might seem.

While writer-director Randall Wallace (who penned "Braveheart" and an early draft of "Pearl Harbor") has true events and real characters on his side (the film is based on a book by Moore and a UPI photographer who documented the battle), he's sometimes too obvious about just who will die. Among the major characters are a gruff, leathery sergeant major (Sam Elliott) who has already fought in two wars and prefers a .45 pistol to the M-16, a fearless helicopter pilot (Greg Kinnear in a surprisingly durable performance) and a 2nd Lieutenant Jack Geoghegan (Chris Klein), a new father and an All-American boy who wears a child's bracelet with his newborn daughter's name on it and has built schools for orphans in Africa.

I'd say "oh, brother," but Wallace didn't make this stuff up. OK, maybe the bracelet. But the important thing is that after effectively personalizing the first two deaths on the battlefield, Wallace keeps the rest of the casualties equally cogent without being theatrical about it.

Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for the film's well-timed breaks from the combat. When "We Were Soldiers" returns to the home front for a subplot revolving around the wives (led by Madeline Stowe as the stalwart Mrs. Moore), Wallace starts strong then slaps you in the face with cheap emotional manipulation. The film's most powerful, heartbreaking scene, involving the Army's failure to properly deliver the dreaded telegrams of regret, is ruined by a gratuitously maudlin montage of wives crying through screen doors, superimposed over a waving American flag.

Every time Wallace takes a breather from the bullets, he plays to the balcony in this manner. "Daddy, what's a war?" Moore's precious 5-year-old daughter asks in a highly scripted tender moment before his departure. Later cases of overkill include a pretentious montage of black-and-white battle photos, and one of those ridiculous, only-in-the-movies scenes of a soldier ringing his own doorbell so his wife can burst into tears at the sight of him.

But for all my complaints, each time the firing resumed, I tensed up something fierce. "We Were Soldiers" captures the chaos of this battle that was a harbinger of things to come, the grave danger breathing down the neck of every combatant (both American and Vietnamese), and especially the heroism that resulted.

What's more, Wallace finds potent and invigoratingly novel ways to illustrate these elements. A pilot's point-of-view shot as a supply helicopter encounters anti-aircraft fire in the night sky is incredible. An image of a dead soldier's legs hanging over the side as that chopper lifts off minutes later has just as strong an impact, and so does the sight of blood being washed out of the back of the huey when it later lands at the base of operations.

The close-quarters combat comes through forcefully in a scene of wounded Americans firing at the encroaching hoards even as they cradle bandaged body parts, and especially a gasp-inspiring shot of a surrounded unit holed up in the dark as Vietnamese soldiers advance silently on their position.

"I need illumination!" a commander whispers desperately into the radio. A few seconds later, a mortar flare bathes the whole area in an instant of frightful light, revealing dozens of the enemy barely arm's length away, with weapons drawn.

When the U.S. Army finally gets organized enough to try to extract Moore's battalion, the subsequent buzz-bombing and napalming packs a mighty cinematic punch too.

Wallace falls back on Hollywood contrivance in the battle's finale, which isn't very clear about how the Americans emerged victorious except to imply that it involved the absurd concept of noisy helicopters somehow sneaking up on the enemy. But while occasional combat exaggeration or overwrought tear duct-poking undercut the greatness potential of "We Were Soldiers," the film is still an imposing and inspiring war film that's true to the spirit of Lt. Col. Moore, who always stood by his promise to be the first man to set foot on a battlefield and the last one to leave.



We Were Soldiers

Facts and Figures

Run time: 138 mins

In Theaters: Friday 1st March 2002

Box Office USA: $78.1M

Box Office Worldwide: $114.7M

Budget: $75M

Distributed by: Paramount Pictures

Production compaines: Paramount Pictures, Icon Productions

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 3 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 63%
Fresh: 90 Rotten: 53

IMDB: 7.1 / 10

Cast & Crew

Director:

Starring: as Lt. Col. Hal Moore, as Maj. Bruce 'Snake' Crandall, as Julie Moore, as Sgt. Maj. Basil Plumley, as 2nd Lt. Jack Geoghegan, as Barbara Geoghegan, as Joe Galloway, as Capt. Tom Metsker, as 2nd Lt. Henry Herrick, as Capt. Tony Nadal, Robert Bagnell as 1st Lt. Charlie Hastings, Blake Heron as Sp4 Galen Bungum, Josh Daugherty as Sp4 Robert Ouellette, as Capt. Matt Dillon, as Capt. Robert Edwards, Erik MacArthur as Sp4 Russell Adams, Mark McCracken as Capt. Ed 'Too Tall' Freeman, as Sp4 Bill Beck, Duong Don as Lt. Col. Nguyen Huu An, as Sgt. Ernie Savage

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Wind River Movie Review

Wind River Movie Review

After writing the superb Sicario and Hell or High Water, Taylor Sheridan moves back into...

The Vault Movie Review

The Vault Movie Review

Filmmakers Dan Bush and Conal Byrne attempt a mash-up of a frantic heist movie with...

Goon: Last of the Enforcers Movie Review

Goon: Last of the Enforcers Movie Review

The 2012 Canadian comedy Goon was one of those surprising little films that snuck up...

Detroit Movie Review

Detroit Movie Review

After The Hurt Locker and Zero Dark Thirty, Kathryn Bigelow and Mark Boal reteam to...

Logan Lucky Movie Review

Logan Lucky Movie Review

Good news: Steven Soderbergh's well-publicised retirement from directing only lasted about four years. He's back...

American Made Movie Review

American Made Movie Review

An enjoyably freewheeling tone and Tom Cruise's star wattage combine to make this an entertaining...

An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power Movie Review

An Inconvenient Sequel: Truth to Power Movie Review

It's been a decade since Al Gore's wake-up-call documentary won the Oscar. And here he...

Advertisement
The Hitman's Bodyguard Movie Review

The Hitman's Bodyguard Movie Review

It really doesn't matter that this movie is utterly ridiculous, because the central pairing of...

Final Portrait Movie Review

Final Portrait Movie Review

A relaxed, amusing true story about noted Swiss painter and sculptor Alberto Giacometti, this sharply...

Tom of Finland Movie Review

Tom of Finland Movie Review

Finnish artist Tuoko Laaksonen used the name "Tom of Finland" as he drew explicit illustrations...

A Ghost Story Movie Review

A Ghost Story Movie Review

Filmmaker David Lowery reunites the stars from his offbeat Western Ain't Them Bodies Saints for...

Atomic Blonde Movie Review

Atomic Blonde Movie Review

From the co-director of John Wick, this similarly styled action romp puts Charlize Theron front...

Girls Trip Movie Review

Girls Trip Movie Review

This movie's premise basically sounds like The Hangover with added black girl power. But it's...

Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie Movie Review

Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie Movie Review

There's so much manic energy in this animated action comedy that it can't help but...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.