The Human Stain

"Weak"

The Human Stain Review


Miramax makes its initial bid for Oscar gold with The Human Stain, Robert Benton's torpid adaptation of Philip Roth's acclaimed novel about race and sex and lots of other "big" issues such as the price one pays - emotionally, psychologically, professionally - for attempting to flee both the past and one's true self. Yet this lifelessly structured film feels like a puzzle with too many identical parts, each character merely another example of the film's painfully obvious moral lessons. Throw in some ridiculous miscasting and a facile Clinton-Lewinsky scandal backdrop, and what you've got is a film drunk on its own highfalutin melodrama.

Anthony Hopkins is Coleman Silk, a Classics professor at a Massachusetts university, who, because of an alleged racial epithet (he refers to delinquent African-American students as "spooks"), is not only forced into early retirement, but also into unexpected bachelorhood after his wife suddenly drops dead from the news. Coleman is an erudite Jewish man who harbors a great secret about his past, and soon his tortured life has become intertwined with kindred souls. He befriends the reclusive Nathan Zuckerman (Gary Sinise), a novelist who has retired to a remote cabin after a cancer scare has left him petrified of his own mortality. Soon afterwards, he meets a striking post office janitor named Faunia Farley (Nicole Kidman), who, because of a former marriage and a terrible accident, fervently shuns the outside world. Coleman and Faunia strike up a May-December romance, much to the chagrin of both Faunia's loco ex-husband Lester (Ed Harris) and a community whose fascination with Clinton's sexual indiscretions hints at an illogical obsession with political correctness.

A contemporary retread of racial issues tackled far more eloquently by Douglas Sirk's 1959 Imitation of Life, Benton's The Human Stain alternates between the past and the present to show how Coleman's supposedly liberating decision as a young man (he's played by newcomer Wentworth Miller in these flashbacks) winds up imprisoning him in a web of deceit. Yet courtesy of Nicholas Meyer's clunky screenplay, Roth's sharp, incisive prose is replaced by ham-fisted dialogue laced with ludicrous double entendres, such as when, in response to Coleman asking his nubile blonde college sweetheart how she likes her coffee, she casually replies that she likes it "black." Later, Kidman's Faunia has a seriously loopy conversation with a crow, musing that the caged bird is "a crow who doesn't know how to be a crow." The symbolic weight of her comment lands, like most of the film's vain attempts at profundity, with a dull thud.

Without revealing the film's anticlimactic revelation, one can safely say that the Welsh-born Hopkins is a perfect fit for the role of Coleman Silk except in the one area that's most vital to the story. Nonetheless, Hopkins turns in a suitably world-weary performance as a beleaguered intellectual desperate to find some measure of inner peace, even if the script continually wants to amplify his tragic character by analogizing his plight to that of Greek mythology's Achilles. Sinise is given the thankless role of being a passive observer (his character provides the film's narration), while Harris uses his limited screen time as the unstable Lester to take a big, healthy bite of the scenery. Kidman, on the other hand, goes for understatement in both gesture and appearance in conveying Faunia's sexual hunger as a mechanism for denial. What she can't do, however, is change the fact that, despite a brunette dye job, some ugly tank tops, and endless chain-smoking, she's still the world's most unbelievably good-looking janitor.

Scant extras on the DVD, with a behind the scenes special and a tribute to cinematographer Jean Yves Escoffier.

A little club soda will get that stain out.



The Human Stain

Facts and Figures

Run time: 106 mins

In Theaters: Wednesday 29th October 2003

Box Office USA: $5.3M

Budget: $30M

Distributed by: Miramax Films

Production compaines: Miramax Films, Lakeshore Entertainment, Stone Village Pictures, Cinerenta Medienbeteiligungs KG

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 2 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 43%
Fresh: 64 Rotten: 86

IMDB: 6.3 / 10

Cast & Crew

Director:

Starring: as Coleman Silk, as Faunia Farley, as Lester Farley, as Nathan Zuckerman, as Young Coleman Silk, as Steena Paulsson, as Mr. Silk, as Nelson Primus, as Mrs. Silk, Lizan Mitchell as Ernestine, Phyllis Newman as Iris Silk, as Psychologist

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Their Finest Movie Review

Their Finest Movie Review

Skilfully written, directed and acted, this offbeat British period film tells a story that catches...

Unforgettable Movie Review

Unforgettable Movie Review

With heavy echoes of trashy thrillers like Fatal Attraction, this movie overcomes its painfully simplistic...

The Belko Experiment Movie Review

The Belko Experiment Movie Review

The kill-or-die scenario that this movie hinges on isn't something new; it's been used in...

The Fate of the Furious Movie Review

The Fate of the Furious Movie Review

With the more dumbed-down title Fast & Furious 8 outside of North America, this overcrowded...

A Quiet Passion Movie Review

A Quiet Passion Movie Review

British writer-director Terence Davies (The Deep Blue Sea) is an expert at digging beneath the...

The Sense of an Ending Movie Review

The Sense of an Ending Movie Review

Julian Barnes' Booker Prize-winning novel is adapted into a remarkably intelligent, gently involving film anchored...

The Boss Baby Movie Review

The Boss Baby Movie Review

There isn't a lot of subtlety in this madcap animated comedy, which is more aimed...

Advertisement
City of Tiny Lights Movie Review

City of Tiny Lights Movie Review

After the latest incarnation of Dredd, director Pete Travis shifts gears drastically for this complex...

Going in Style Movie Review

Going in Style Movie Review

This is only technically a remake of the iconic 1979 film starring movie icons George...

Graduation Movie Review

Graduation Movie Review

Romanian filmmaker Cristian Mungiu (4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days) recounts another staggeringly detailed...

Ghost in the Shell Movie Review

Ghost in the Shell Movie Review

This sci-fi thriller is so visually stunning that it deserves to be mentioned in the...

Free Fire Movie Review

Free Fire Movie Review

Basically a 90-minute shoot-out, there isn't a lot to this movie. British filmmaker Ben Wheatley...

Life Movie Review

Life Movie Review

Like a mash-up of Alien and Gravity, this ripping sci-fi horror movie is very effective...

The Lost City of Z Movie Review

The Lost City of Z Movie Review

Based on a true story, it's the historical aspect of these events that holds the...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.