Forgiving Dr. Mengele

"Good"

Forgiving Dr. Mengele Review


There are many things one expects to hear from Holocaust survivors when they talk about the Nazis who imprisoned and tortured them in concentration camps, but forgiveness is hardly one of them. Although the tough-as-nails survivor Eva Kor would be a remarkable subject for a documentary even without her quixotic quest to publicize her forgiveness of the Nazi doctor who experimented on her and her twin sister at Auschwitz, the fact that she is doing so just makes her all the more fascinating -- and controversial. It's one thing for Eva to say that she forgives Mengele and all the Nazis for what they did, and quite another for her to advise other survivors of the Holocaust to do the same: "Forgive your worst enemy... it will set you free." Not surprisingly, many of her fellow survivors take issue with this. Bob Hercules and Cheri Pugh's documentary Forgiving Dr. Mengele tries to come to grips with what Eva is talking about, remaining impressively nonjudgmental towards either side of the argument.

Born in Transylvania, Eva was sent with her family to Auschwitz at the age of ten. She and her twin Miriam were separated from the rest of the family -- none of whom survived -- specifically so that Mengele could perform his twisted experiments on them. Nine months later, the camp was liberated by the Soviets. After living in Israel, Eva married and moved with her husband to Terre Haute, where she is now a real estate broker. (Miriam died in 1993 due to complications with her kidneys, severely damaged during one of Mengele's experiments.) Today, Eva cuts an incongruous figure in the small Midwestern city: a hard-charging businesswoman in garish clothes with a strong peasant's build and a thick Eastern European accent, her faded Auschwitz tattoo still visible on her left arm.

Having decided that she was sick of being a victim, Eva made a shocking announcement of forgiveness at the fiftieth anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. Even though she was careful to say that she was speaking only for herself and not for other victims or survivors, the comments angered many and ignited a controversy that still flares up today. The film follows Eva over the course of the last few years to her many public appearances at schools and conferences, making allies and enemies in almost equal numbers. Championed as a hero by people in Terre Haute -- where she runs a small Holocaust museum out of a strip mall -- Eva is just as vehemently attacked by others, who accuse her of trying to whitewash a great evil and of granting what one critic calls "cheap grace."

Although the filmmakers do their best to stay on the fence about Eva's views (though the film is resolutely impressed with her survivor's stamina), it's difficult not to feel as though many of these charges are gratuitous. Who has the right, after all, to tell a Holocaust survivor that forgiving her enemies in order to get on with her life is wrong? While the film is excellent at raising such questions as these, it has definite problems from an artistic standpoint. Structurally, the filmmakers tend to ramble and lose the string of their plotline. A later section in which Eva goes to Israel to see family and also meet with some Palestinian teachers and an Israeli peace activist -- a scenario which shows the limit of Eva's forgiveness -- is interesting in and of itself but is only loosely tied to the main body of the film. Forgiving Dr. Mengele is a rickety thing, all told, but it tells a powerful and unique story with no easy resolution.



Forgiving Dr. Mengele

Facts and Figures

In Theaters: Sunday 1st January 2006

Distributed by: First Run Features

Reviews

Contactmusic.com: 3 / 5

Rotten Tomatoes: 90%
Fresh: 19 Rotten: 2

IMDB: 7.1 / 10

Cast & Crew

Director: Bob Hercules, Cheri Pugh

Producer: Bob Hercules, Cheri Pugh

Starring: Eva Mozes Kor as Herself

Contactmusic


Links



Advertisement

New Movies

Churchill Movie Review

Churchill Movie Review

This drama about the iconic British prime minister tells a darkly personal story set over...

Gifted Movie Review

Gifted Movie Review

This is one of those films that dances right up to the edge of soapy...

Whitney: Can I Be Me Movie Review

Whitney: Can I Be Me Movie Review

Notorious British filmmaker Nick Broomfield teams up with Austrian music documentary producer Rudi Dolezal to...

The Mummy Movie Review

The Mummy Movie Review

To launch their new Dark Universe franchise, Universal has taken an approach that mixes murky...

My Cousin Rachel Movie Review

My Cousin Rachel Movie Review

Daphne du Maurier's 1951 mystery-romance novel has been adapted for theatre, radio, TV and film,...

Wilson Movie Review

Wilson Movie Review

It's never helpful when a comedy becomes a bit too smug about its own quirkiness....

Interlude in Prague Movie Review

Interlude in Prague Movie Review

A fictionalised story from the life of Wolfgang Mozart, this lavishly produced period drama is...

Advertisement
The Hippopotamus Movie Review

The Hippopotamus Movie Review

This British satirical comedy may be a bit of a mess, but since it's based...

Detour Movie Review

Detour Movie Review

This may look like a rather typical American indie thriller, but British filmmaker Christopher Smith...

Wonder Woman Movie Review

Wonder Woman Movie Review

Boldly optimistic, this action-packed adventure breathes fresh life into the DC universe with a welcome...

Baywatch Movie Review

Baywatch Movie Review

Clearly, it's a risky proposition adapting a cheesy vintage TV series for the big screen:...

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales Movie Review

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales Movie Review

Subtitled Salazar's Revenge in the UK, this fifth film in the long-running series never quite...

Colossal Movie Review

Colossal Movie Review

It's rare to find a movie that so defiantly refuses to be put into a...

King Arthur: Legend of the Sword Movie Review

King Arthur: Legend of the Sword Movie Review

It's unlikely that Guy Ritchie could make a boring movie if he wanted to. This...

Advertisement
Artists
Actors
    Filmmakers
      Artists
      Bands
        Musicians
          Artists
          Celebrities
             
              Artists
              Interviews
                musicians & bands in the news
                  actors & filmmakers in the news
                    celebrities in the news

                      Go Back in Time using our News archive to see what happened on a particular day in the past.